All Play and No Nuisance: A Noise Complaint Falls Short
In Kaur v. Waterloo Condominium Corporation No. 61, Jovanovic, Jovanovic, the Applicant was an owner of a unit located below the Respondents, who were parents of a young child. The Applicant experienced (second hand) what many parents are familiar with – young children like to play (and are not concerned with the noise they make while doing so). Over several months, the Applicant submitted over 40 noise complaints to the condominium corporation, including reports of running, heavy footsteps, stomping and dropping of objects coming from the Respondents’ unit. Despite these well documented complaints, the Condominium Authority Tribunal (“CAT”) dismissed the application, finding that the noise in question was consistent with normal daily living (in the particular building) and also finding that the condominium corporation took reasonable steps to investigate and respond to the Applicant’s concerns.
In this case, the Tribunal considered subsection 117(2) of the Condominium Act (the “Act”) which prohibits residents from carrying on activities that create a nuisance, annoyance or disruption to individuals in another unit or the common elements. The Tribunal was also guided by the common law principle that, in order for a nuisance at law to be present, the subject activity must be both “substantial” and “unreasonable”. Assessing factors such as the frequency, duration, and intensity of the activity, and whether the activity is “trivial”, also help the decision-maker determine whether the subject activity amounts to a nuisance at law.
After hearing evidence from the parties, the CAT found that the noise generated from the Respondents’ child playing was, in fact, intermittent, low intensity, and occurred within reasonable hours during the day. In the Tribunal’s words, the noise was “not beyond what ought to be reasonably expected in a common living situation”.
With respect to the Applicant’s claim that the corporation failed to take reasonable steps to enforce compliance with the Act and investigate their noise complaints, the Tribunal – again – disagreed. Rather, the CAT found that the corporation acted reasonably by, amongst other actions:
- Responding to the Applicant’s emails;
- Writing and speaking with the Respondent owners about the reported noise;
- Requesting the Applicant to, if possible, provide audio recordings and report the noise to the corporation’s superintendent so that the noise could be verified; and
- Arranging for an engineer to perform acoustic testing in both units (which the Applicant, notably, refused to provide access to facilitate).
After taking these steps, the corporation could not verify the Applicant’s claim that the reported noise amounted to an unreasonable nuisance. While the Applicant was (clearly) not satisfied with the corporation’s response, the Tribunal found that, in the circumstances of the case, the corporation had discharged its duties, and added that the corporation was not necessarily required to take steps dictated by the Applicant.
Overall, this case highlights that, when responding to noise complaints, the corporation should take all reasonable steps to investigate those complaints. If such investigations reveal non-compliance with the Act, then enforcement action would be appropriate. In all cases, the complaining owner should take all reasonable steps to assist the condominium corporation’s investigations, including providing access to their unit as may be necessary. This case also serves as a good reminder that condominium living requires the give-and-take of being part of a community—even when that includes the occasional patter of little feet.
Stay tuned to Condo Law News to keep up to date on the latest developments on condominium law !
